How to win "fraudulent" chargebacks

---

The "Fraudulent" chargeback, explained

A customer told their bank they never made the purchase. Stolen card, or someone used their details without permission.

That's the claim. On Shopify Payments this shows up as reason "Fraudulent" and it's the most common dispute type merchants see.

Two very different things hide behind it:

1. Real fraud. Someone actually used a stolen card. You shipped to a fraudster.
2. Friendly fraud. The real cardholder bought it, then disputed it anyway. Forgot the purchase, regretted it, or a family member ordered it.

The bank can't tell the difference from their side. Your evidence is what tells them.

What the bank reviewer checks

The reviewer is not reading your story. They check whether the transaction looks like the cardholder made it. So every piece of evidence should connect the buyer to the card.

The list they care about:

• AVS match. Billing address matched the card's address at checkout.
• CVV match. The buyer had the physical card details, not a skimmed number.
• Billing address = shipping address. Fraudsters ship to their address, not the victim's.
• Customer history. Same customer, same card, past orders with no disputes. Strongest friendly-fraud signal there is.
• Device and IP data. Same IP or device as previous legit orders.
• Delivery confirmation to the cardholder's address. Ties the goods to the person claiming they never bought it.
• Any customer contact. They emailed you about the order? A "fraud victim" doesn't ask about shipping times.

One matching AVS + CVV + repeat-customer history beats three pages of explanation. Short and specific wins.

What usually loses

• An angry paragraph about the customer lying. The reviewer skips it.
• Screenshots with no context or no matching order fields.
• Sending "product not received" style evidence (tracking alone) for a fraud claim. Wrong checklist. Tracking helps here, but only next to identity evidence. If your dispute is actually about delivery, that's a different reason code with a different list, see product not received.
• Missing the deadline. Shopify Payments gives you a fixed response window and there are no extensions. A day late is the same as not responding.

How ChargebackWiz handles this reason code

ChargebackWiz reads the dispute the moment Shopify fires the webhook. For a "Fraudulent" claim it pulls from the order automatically:

• AVS and CVV results from the transaction
• Billing vs shipping address comparison
• That customer's full order history in your store
• Tracking and delivery confirmation
• Any notes and contact tied to the order

Then it builds the response packet around the fraud checklist above, not a generic template, and shows you everything before the deadline. You review and submit, or let auto-pilot file it for you.

Honest note: no tool can win a case where a stolen card really was used and nothing links the buyer to the cardholder. What we fix is the losable-but-winnable pile, the friendly-fraud cases merchants lose because the evidence was sitting in Shopify and never made it into the response.

Pricing is a success fee on won disputes. No monthly fee. If we don't win, you don't pay.

Do this in the next 10 minutes

1. Open the dispute in Shopify and confirm the reason code says fraudulent. Wrong code means wrong checklist.
2. Pull AVS/CVV results from the order's payment details.
3. Search the customer's email in your orders. Past orders change everything.
4. Check the deadline. Put it in your calendar today.

Or install ChargebackWiz and it does steps 2 to 4 for every dispute automatically.

New to how the process works end to end? Read how Shopify chargebacks work. Want the written-response structure? Grab the Shopify chargeback response template.

Install ChargebackWiz. Success fee only, no monthly cost. [Install on Shopify]

Common questions

What is friendly fraud? The real cardholder made the purchase and disputed it anyway. Forgot it, regretted it, or someone in their household ordered. It looks identical to real fraud from the bank's side, so your customer-history evidence decides it.

Can I win a fraudulent chargeback on Shopify? Yes, if evidence links the buyer to the cardholder. AVS/CVV matches, billing = shipping, and repeat-purchase history are the big three. Real stolen-card cases with no such link are usually not winnable.

How long do I have to respond? Shopify shows the exact due date on each dispute. The window is fixed and there are no extensions, so check it the day the dispute lands.